Four Email Studies Can't Agree on the Best Send Day. For Fill Reminders, Test the Hour.
Tuesday or Thursday? The studies disagree

Your own list's results beat any vendor's send-day benchmark.
The Situation
A propane dealer who schedules fill reminders and budget-plan renewals by a vendor's "best day to send" is following advice the vendors themselves don't agree on. Brevo's data says Tuesday or Thursday, 10 a.m. to 3 p.m. Moosend's points to Thursday, 8 to 9 a.m. A Sender.net roundup finds Tuesday best in Omnisend's 2026 data and Friday best in MailerLite's 2025 data.
None of these studies looked at propane customers.
The Facts
Sender.net puts the disagreement in perspective. In both the Omnisend and MailerLite datasets, the gap between weekdays is under two percentage points, so the hour and the goal of the email matter more than the day. Omnisend's figure comes from about 26 billion emails and MailerLite's from 2.1 million campaigns.
Brevo's own numbers show why weekends are a poor bet: weekdays account for over 85% of weekly open volume and nearly 95% of weekly click volume on its platform. Moosend's reading is based on its analysis of 10 billion emails sent through its system.
Open rates are the weakest yardstick. Sender.net explains that Apple's Mail Privacy Protection registers an open whether or not the person reads the email, and that Litmus measured Apple clients at roughly 46% of tracked opens in September 2025. Sender.net says that inflation is why MailerLite's average open rates run far higher than Omnisend's.
Business Impact
For a dealer, the email that matters is the one that gets a customer to schedule a fill, sign up for a budget plan or pay a bill. Clicks and replies show that; opens do not.
What this means for your business: 1. A weekday, mid-morning send is a sensible default. 2. Judge your emails by clicks and actions, not opens. 3. Your own list's history is a better guide than any platform benchmark.
Key Data Points
- Brevo: Tuesday or Thursday, 10 a.m. to 3 p.m.
- Moosend: Thursday, 8 to 9 a.m.
- Omnisend 2026: Tuesday (31.27% open rate); MailerLite 2025: Friday (49.72%), per Sender.net.
Key Takeaways
- The studies disagree on the best day, but the weekday gap in the two largest datasets is under two points.
- Open rates are inflated by Apple's privacy feature, so clicks are the better measure.
Action Steps
- 1.Pull last season's fill-reminder and renewal emails from your email platform and note the weekday, send hour and click rate of each.
- 2.Send your next fill reminder at 10 a.m. on a Tuesday to half the list and a Thursday to the other half, then compare clicks and scheduled fills.
- 3.Report clicks and completed actions to your team instead of open rates.
- 4.Ask your email platform whether it offers send-time optimization based on your own list's history.
Competitive Advantage
A dealer who tracks which send times actually produce scheduled fills builds a record no benchmark can supply.
What time did your best-performing fill reminder go out last season?
Get the next one in your inbox.
Free propane industry news, twice a week. 30,000+ operators already read it.
No spam, unsubscribe anytime. We'll email you a link to confirm — that's how we keep the list real. Cloudflare processes a short bot-check token on this form. See our privacy policy.
Published by PropaneInsider.com
AI-powered propane industry news for 30,000+ professionals
Propane Insider is published by the makers of Tank Spotter, Custom Fuel App, Blink Fuel, PIMS and Propane Safety Pro; some links go to advertisers.
